
Icon by Kakamochi
Art Raffle Audit
ABOUT
Art Raffle Audit (Can This Art Raffle Be Trusted? // ARA) is an account created by Big Man Skeeter as a response to the constant influx of art raffles from JRUHUB, similar Indonesian art broker accounts, and South Asia-based art bots. Its purpose is to call out art raffles, artmoot begging posts, or commission advertisements on Twitter/X from bots, known or suspected JRUHUB owned or connected accounts, AI users, tracers or overreferencers, and generally suspicious artists with concerning behaviors. On the flip side, I will also occasionally shout out art raffles or related posts from known / properly audited and trustworthy artists or studios.
WHY SHOULDN'T I JOIN SUSPICIOUS RAFFLES?
You may ask, "Why should I care if I join these suspicious art raffles? I want to get free art 🤷🏻♀️"• Aside from the potential of either getting AI generated images, traced artwork, and / or having an overworked, severely underpaid Indonesian artist be forced to make free art, your stuff CAN get traced, overreferenced, or even stolen outright.
WHAT TO LOOK OUT FOR - BOTS
Note: Individually, some of these are just coincidences, and some are major red flags. When a large amount of these factors are met, you're better off avoiding them.• Engagement bait takes up the majority of their posts
• Art looks traced, artstyle has extreme inconsistency between pieces
• Absence of price listings or refusal to give a price listing outside of DMs
• Aggressive demands for people to become their mutuals in order to get inside of their DMs.
• The same kind of people who will try to friend you on Discord randomly acting as if they are commissions artists.
• Majority of them use generative AI. If you suspect a piece is AI, don't just use a generic AI checker; check for a synthID, which does unfortunately require you to utilize tools made by OpenAI / Google Gemini / Grok, but synthIDs are 99.999% foolproof, as they are essentially the AI's own watermark.
■ OpenAI synthID check
• Lying about their location. Most of these bots are based in South Asia (specifically, Pakistan). Unlike normal South Asian artists, these bots pretend they're from different countries, most of the time, they say they're from the United States of America. Their actual location can be checked via their account information (click the profile's join date)
• Generic names. Be it suburban names like Jessica Smith, Ashley Jones, Steven Paul, etc. Or generic Japanese-ish names like Kitsune vtuber or kittykawaii vtuber, etc.
• Stolen art. Very common. Try using reverse image search on some of their work.
• Lack/absence of timelapses, or timelapses are suspicious
WHAT TO LOOK OUT FOR - JRUHUB
Note: Except for finding direct connections to JRUHUB or being obviously AI/traced/stolen, one or two of these factors is not enough to prove the account cannot be trusted. It's when a large amount of these factors are met.• The "JRUHUB" style: Very saturated and clashing colors, occasionally odd anatomy, extreme inconsistency with art styles between each artwork, sometimes going back and forth in quality and level of skill.
• Raffles are primarily eye banners, mouth banners, YCH (your character here), or even full on Live2D VTuber models - some offer rigging included.
• Many of these JRU accounts' art can be reverse image traced to instagram accounts on InfoLoker / LokerCreative / lokersmg (Indonesian job listings accounts on Instagram.) Look out for listings with anime style characters on the advertisement, and/or looking for those who can draw in an anime style, and the job location being based in Semarang or Jogja.
• If the artist's implied location is different from where their account is actually based in.
• If they are a VTuber who has been pre-debut for ages yet has no twitch / youtube or has nothing on their twitch and much of their content is completely engagement baiting.
• They desperately try to get the attention of VTubers, as they are their main target customer base, usually in the form of posts constantly advertising calling on VTubers, flashy deals and discounts, and making a lot of fanart for big VTubers, @'ing them and begging for people to tag the VTuber for their attention. It is as annoying to look at as it probably is for the VTubers.
• These accounts have the most cookie cutter behavior, primarily abusing the tags: #artmoots #VGenArtist #smallartist
• They beg for mutuals to artificially inflate their follower count without returning interactions, unless the account is large enough.
• The grand majority of them have VArtist in their profile names. This isn't an immediate determining factor, rather as an additional factor to consider.
• Frequent abuse of emojis, usually hearts ❤️💖💞 siren 🚨 sparkle ✨️ on nearly every post
LIST OF ACCOUNTS CALLED OUT
Here is the list of accounts called out
| Name | Call-Out Post |
|---|---|
| Nebura Nekoshima @NeburaNekoshima | POST |
| Sunny Rise @SunSunnyRise | POST |
| Fukosora @Fukosora | POST |
| RizuSorane @RizuSorane | POST |
| ReinaSuki @reinasukistudio | POST |
| Zanshin Studio @zanshinika | POST |
| Gomiu @gomiumiuw | POST |
| Arion Studio @ArionSylven | POST |
| Yori Usami @yoriusamistudio | POST |
| Kepun @KepunBaik | POST |
| Yume @takara_yume | POST |
| Lucky Clover @LuckyCloverArts | POST |
| Vivielle @vivielleartsy | POST |
| Guloku @beingulokuu | POST |
| Midori @midorikobayasih | POST |
| Auralist @auralist_vyn | POST |
| Akinori @akinoristudio | POST |
| Aurensyl @aurensyl | POST |
| Takun Kitchen @takunkitchen | POST |
| Shizukamio @shizukamio_ | POST |
| Akani Yua @akaniyuaa | POST |
| Mikaan @mikanakeno | POST |
| Nexcyza @Nexcyza | POST |
| Reina Akahoshi @ReinaAkahoshi | POST |
| Ba Blust @bablustanime | POST |
| ReinaSuki @reinasukistudio | POST |
| LynxLab @LynxLab | POST |
| Showann @showann2706 | POST |
| Ara @Araaaabella_ | POST |
| Lunash @lunashdegrace | POST |
| Kaito @KaitoRyujin_ | POST |
| Aikoryn @aikorynstudio | POST |
| Ai Nakayama/Pawtoon @PawtoonStudio | POST |
| Machiko @Machikotammy | POST |
| Akame @AkameRenata | POST |
| Raimoo @raimoow | POST |
| Nerina @nerinahazuki | POST |
Petalouda @_petalouda_ | POST |
| Panikro @panikro_ | POST |
| Hikarume @hikarumee_ | POST |
| RosyBerry @RosyBerryyy | POST |
| Kaito Zennin @kaito_zennin | POST |
| MomoMiw @Momooomiw | POST |
| Hoshi @HoshiMaison | POST |
| Maskey @Maskey_Artist | POST |
| Millie Bloom @ArtByMillie1 | POST |
| MikaRose @MikaRose_Vt | POST |
| Sakura Vtuber Studio @Sakura_HarunoVT | POST |
| Yuzu @yuzukarenn | POST |
| Rora @roramizuki | POST |
| Keiko Hana @keikohanachan | POST |
| Zyra @zyra_amaris | POST |
| Ayakakurenai @ayakakurenaii | POST |
| Autumn @autumnmdove | POST |
| Gawr Gura (No, not the actual Gura) @GawrGura_VTuber | POST |
| Ayanda VT @Ayanda_VT | POST |
| Aeloria EX @aeloriaex | POST |
| Moonl1gh8 @moonl1gh8 | POST |
| VtuberxJade @VtuberxJade | POST |
| HAZEFURR @HAZEFURR | POST |
| Susanenvt @susanenvt | POST |
ImMaya_vt @ImMaya_Vt | POST |
Oliveo @wanna_lost_ | POST |
Special Thanks
Special thanks to:
● Ethical Art Hub for providing extensive documentation for the public on JRUHUB accounts and JRUHUB adjacent accounts
● ID.ASH for featuring trustworthy Indonesian artists and helping out the Indo art community
● Zynoa for bringing up the JRUHUB issue to light front and center
● Kat n Chat, Zya, Nimis, and many more for videos calling out JRUHUB / bringing attention to the JRUHUB situation
● All the people who have been calling out JRUHUB, bots, and bad actors
● Last but not least, my investigation team, thank you so much for all you do
Documentation
The majority of documentation used for JRUHUB and JRUHUB-adjacent accounts is courtesy of Ethical Art Hub's public JRUHUB account index:📃 ACCOUNT INDEX
📃 WHAT IS JRUHUB